Smudger (voiced by John Paul Karliak) is a narrow-gauge tank engine. During his days at the Mid-Sodor Railway, he was a show-off who rode roughly and often came off the rails. Duke tried to warn him to be careful, but Smudger never listened to his advice. He was finally punished by being turned into a generator and being put behind the engine shed.
When the Mid-Sodor Railway closed, some people came to buy Smudger for their Narrow Gauge Railway in England. He was still a generator there until the people who bought him raise enough money to turn Smudger back into an engine. He already learned from his mistakes during his time as a generator, became a better engine and rode much better then he did back at the Mid-Sodor Railway. A few years later, Smudger was found by .